How Import Tariffs Affect the Economy and Trade: A Comprehensive Guide
Import tariffs are taxes that governments impose on imported goods to influence trade, raise revenues, or protect domestic industries. They can have various effects on the economy and trade, depending on their type, level, and duration. In this article, we will explain what import tariffs are, why they are used, what types of tariffs exist, and what are their advantages and disadvantages.
What Are Import Tariffs?
According to Investopedia, a tariff is “a tax imposed by one country on the goods and services imported from another country to influence it, raise revenues, or protect competitive advantages.” Tariffs are usually expressed as a percentage of the value of the imported goods or as a fixed amount per unit of goods. For example, a 10% ad valorem tariff means that the importer has to pay 10% of the value of the goods as a tax to the government. A $500 specific tariff means that the importer has to pay $500 for each unit of goods imported.
Tariffs are one of the most common instruments of protectionism, which is a policy that aims to restrict or discourage imports and favor domestic production. Tariffs can also be used as a tool of foreign policy, to exert pressure or retaliation on other countries for political or economic reasons.
Why Are Import Tariffs Used?
Governments may have different motives for imposing import tariffs, such as:
Raising revenues
Tariffs can generate income for the government from the importers who have to pay them. For example, in 2020, the U.S. government collected $21 billion in customs duties from various tariffs imposed on imports from China, Europe, and other countries.
Protecting domestic industries
Tariffs can make imported goods more expensive and less competitive than domestic goods, thus reducing the demand for imports and increasing the demand for local production. This can help protect domestic industries from foreign competition and create or save jobs in the domestic economy. For example, in 2022, President Joe Biden proposed a 25% ad valorem tariff on steel articles from all countries except Canada, Mexico, and the U.K., to protect U.S. steel manufacturing and production jobs.
Protecting domestic consumers
Tariffs can also be used to protect domestic consumers from low-quality or unsafe imported goods, by making them more costly or unaffordable. For example, some countries may impose high tariffs on imported food products that do not meet their health or environmental standards.
Protecting national interests
Tariffs can also be used to advance national interests or goals, such as promoting national security, human rights, environmental protection, or economic development. For example, some countries may impose tariffs on imports from countries that violate human rights or support terrorism, or on imports that harm the environment or threaten national security.
What Types of Import Tariffs Exist?
There are two main types of import tariffs: specific tariffs and ad valorem tariffs.
Specific tariffs: These are fixed amounts of tax levied per unit of imported goods. They do not depend on the value of the goods. For example, a $500 specific tariff on cars means that every car imported has to pay $500 as a tax, regardless of its price.
Ad valorem tariffs: These are percentages of tax levied on the value of imported goods. They depend on the price of the goods. For example, a 10% ad valorem tariff on cars means that every car imported has to pay 10% of its price as a tax.
There are also other types of tariffs that combine specific and ad valorem elements, such as:
Compound tariffs: These are tariffs that consist of both a specific and an ad valorem component. For example, a compound tariff on cars could be $500 plus 10% of the value.
Alternative tariffs: These are tariffs that allow the importer to choose between paying a specific or an ad valorem tariff, whichever is lower. For example, an alternative tariff on cars could be $500 or 10% of the value, whichever is less.
What Are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Import Tariffs?
Import tariffs can have various advantages and disadvantages for different groups in society, such as:
Government: The main advantage for the government is that tariffs can generate revenues that can be used for public spending or debt reduction. The main disadvantage is that tariffs can provoke trade disputes or retaliation from other countries that may harm diplomatic relations or economic cooperation.
Domestic producers: The main advantage for domestic producers is that tariffs can reduce foreign competition and increase their market share and profits. The main disadvantage is that tariffs can increase their production costs if they rely on imported inputs or intermediate goods.
Domestic consumers: The main advantage for domestic consumers is that tariffs can protect them from low-quality or unsafe imported goods. The main disadvantage is that tariffs can increase the prices of imported goods or reduce their availability, thus lowering their purchasing power and welfare.
Foreign producers: The main advantage for foreign producers is that tariffs can create an incentive for them to improve their quality or efficiency to remain competitive in the foreign market. The main disadvantage is that tariffs can reduce their sales and profits in the foreign market or force them out of the market altogether.
Foreign consumers: The main advantage for foreign consumers is that tariffs can create an incentive for domestic producers to export more of their goods to the foreign market, thus increasing their supply and lowering their prices. The main disadvantage is that tariffs can reduce the variety or quality of goods available in the foreign market.
What Are the Effects of Import Tariffs on the Economy and Trade?
Import tariffs can have various effects on the economy and trade, such as:
Price effect: Tariffs increase the price of imported goods, which can lead to a decrease in the quantity demanded by domestic consumers and an increase in the quantity supplied by domestic producers. This creates a deadweight loss of consumer and producer surplus, which is a measure of economic inefficiency. Tariffs also create a government revenue, which is a transfer of surplus from consumers and producers to the government.
Output effect: Tariffs reduce the quantity of imports and increase the quantity of domestic production, which can lead to a reallocation of resources from more efficient to less efficient sectors in the economy. This can lower the overall productivity and growth potential of the economy.
Employment effect: Tariffs can create or save jobs in the protected domestic industries, but they can also destroy jobs in other sectors that rely on imports or exports. The net effect on employment depends on the elasticity of demand and supply for the imported goods, the availability and mobility of factors of production, and the overall macroeconomic conditions.
Trade effect: Tariffs reduce the volume and value of trade between countries, which can lower the gains from trade and specialization. Tariffs can also distort the terms of trade, which is the ratio of export prices to import prices. A higher terms of trade means that a country can buy more imports with a given amount of exports, which improves its welfare. A lower terms of trade means that a country has to sell more exports to buy a given amount of imports, which lowers its welfare.
Welfare effect: Tariffs affect the welfare of different groups in society in different ways. Generally, tariffs benefit the government and the domestic producers in the protected industries, but harm the domestic consumers and the foreign producers in the affected industries. The net effect on social welfare depends on the size and distribution of the gains and losses from tariffs.
Import tariffs are taxes that governments impose on imported goods to influence trade, raise revenues, or protect domestic industries. They can have various effects on the economy and trade, depending on their type, level, and duration. Import tariffs can benefit some groups in society, but harm others, and create economic inefficiency and deadweight loss. Import tariffs can also provoke trade disputes or retaliation from other countries that may escalate into trade wars.
How Import Tariffs Affect Global Demand
Import tariffs are taxes imposed by a country on goods and services imported from other countries. They are usually intended to protect domestic industries from foreign competition, raise government revenue, or achieve some other policy objective. However, import tariffs also have an impact on global demand, which is the total amount of goods and services that consumers and businesses in the world want to buy.
The Effect of Import Tariffs on Global Demand: A Theoretical Perspective
According to the standard theory of international trade, import tariffs affect global demand in two ways: by changing the relative prices of goods and services across countries, and by affecting the income and welfare of consumers and producers in both the importing and exporting countries.
First, import tariffs increase the price of imported goods and services relative to domestic ones in the importing country. This reduces the demand for imports and increases the demand for domestic substitutes. Conversely, import tariffs reduce the price of exported goods and services relative to domestic ones in the exporting country. This reduces the demand for domestic products and increases the demand for exports. Therefore, import tariffs tend to shift global demand away from the products of countries that impose them and towards the products of countries that face them.
Second, import tariffs affect the income and welfare of consumers and producers in both the importing and exporting countries. In general, import tariffs benefit the producers of domestic substitutes in the importing country, who can sell more at a higher price, and harm the consumers of imported goods and services in the importing country, who have to pay more for less. Similarly, import tariffs benefit the consumers of exported goods and services in the exporting country, who can buy more at a lower price, and harm the producers of exports in the exporting country, who have to sell less at a lower price. Therefore, import tariffs tend to increase the income and welfare of some groups and decrease the income and welfare of others, both within and across countries.
The net effect of import tariffs on global demand depends on how these two effects interact. In general, import tariffs reduce global demand if they lower the overall income and welfare of the world, or if they create more distortions in relative prices than they correct. Conversely, import tariffs increase global demand if they raise the overall income and welfare of the world, or if they correct more distortions in relative prices than they create.
The Effect of Import Tariffs on Global Demand: An Empirical Perspective
The theoretical effect of import tariffs on global demand is not easy to measure empirically, because it depends on many factors, such as the size and structure of the economies involved, the elasticity of demand and supply for different goods and services, the degree of market power and competition in different sectors, and the existence and magnitude of other trade barriers and policies. However, some studies have attempted to estimate this effect using various methods and data sources.
One approach is to use historical data on tariff rates and trade flows to estimate how changes in import tariffs affect global demand over time. For example, a recent study by Bagwell et al. (2022) uses a newly built dataset of pre-Uruguay Round applied tariffs and relies on the theoretical framework of the terms-of-trade motive for trade agreements to estimate hypothetical tariff commitments under current levels of market power and compare them with actual tariff commitments. The study finds that most countries have committed to lower tariffs than they would have chosen unilaterally under current market conditions, implying that trade agreements have increased global demand by reducing trade distortions.
Another approach is to use cross-sectional data on tariff rates and trade flows to estimate how differences in import tariffs affect global demand across countries. For example, a recent publication by the World Trade Organization (WTO), the International Trade Centre (ITC), and
the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) provides comprehensive information on the tariffs and non-tariff measures imposed by over 170 countries and customs territories. The publication also provides summary tables that allow cross-country comparisons of average tariff rates for different product categories, as well as import statistics that show export diversification and relevant tariff data for each economy. The publication can be used to analyze how variations in import tariffs affect global demand across products and markets.
References:
https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/6958854.pdf
https://web.archive.org/web/20171207055442/https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/6958854.pdf
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/tariff.asp
https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/stats/trade
https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/presidential-actions/2022/05/28/a-proclamation-on-adjusting-imports-of-steel-into-the-united-states/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tariff
https://gerlach-customs.com/customs-glossary/import-tariffs/
https://penpoin.com/import-tariff/
Essential Topics You Should Be Familiar With:
